Skip to content

Beaumont City Council Approves $794,900 John Deere Landfill Dozer 6-1

The vote came over a dissenting council member's objection that staff had not adequately vetted used equipment alternatives for the Solid Waste Fund purchase.

A yellow John Deere 1050 P-Tier crawler dozer pushing boulders across a rocky site under a blue sky
A John Deere 1050 P-Tier dozer, in a photo from John Deere. Image Credit: John Deere

The Beaumont City Council voted 6-1 on Oct. 20 to spend $794,900 from the Solid Waste Fund on a new John Deere landfill dozer. Mayor Pro Tem Cory Crenshaw, who cast the lone no vote, said he had asked to table the item so staff could present used and lease options, but was not allowed to do so.

Crenshaw questioned whether staff had done enough research before bringing the purchase forward. “I’m just not buying it that you have used equipment auctions going on all over the country and you have leasing programs and they’re just financially make zero sense to ever buy a used dozer or lease a dozer,” he said. He said he would oppose the purchase specifically because he did not believe staff had vetted used equipment with enough due diligence. “I get in a landfill environment, a lease doesn’t make sense, which is why my original comment was, ‘Did the city do any due diligence vetting used equipment,’ and so because I do not believe that staff has done due diligence in vetting used equipment for this project, I’ll be against it,” he said.

City Manager Chris Boone said the questions were fair. “I think it’s a fair question to ask. Just as we all do in our own homes. Is it better to lease or purchase? Is it better to buy new or used? These are all the questions we ask ourselves for all kinds of things. I don’t want it to look like we’re not asking those questions,” Boone said.

The machine being replaced is a 2014 Caterpillar D8T. A staff memo shared by Crenshaw after the vote shows the dozer was rebuilt in June 2020 at roughly 13,554 hours, at a cost of about $463,000. Since that rebuild, it has logged another 10,069 hours for a total of about 23,623 frame hours. The memo notes that landfill dozers are typically rebuilt every 11,000 to 13,000 hours.

A certified rebuild estimate for a comparable D8T, dated April 4, 2025, came in at $658,604. Fleet staff presented two new-equipment options: the John Deere unit at $794,900 and a Komatsu model at $1,230,570. Staff recommended the new purchase, citing the rebuild cost, availability of equipment from multiple manufacturers and the warranty on a new machine. City officials confirmed the purchase was already budgeted through the Solid Waste Fund.

Crenshaw said a remark by the fleet manager at the meeting left him with the impression the city had spent about $700,000 on the rebuild a few years ago, which he called a red flag. The staff memo put the figure at about $463,000.

The council also considered purchasing 12 golf carts for Henry Homberg Golf Course at $109,958.76; that item did not pass.

The Sightline

Public fleet intel, delivered

The stories, data, and best practices that matter, straight to your inbox. No fluff. No spam. Just the good stuff.

By signing up, you agree to receive communications from Modern Public Fleet and its trusted partners. See our Privacy Policy. Unsubscribe any time.